Pharmacy, COVID-19 and the Future

Knowledge and challenges of pharmacists in Ghana during the COVID-19 pandemic

On this page

Knowledge and challenges of pharmacists in Ghana during the COVID-19 pandemic

Mercy N. A. Opare-Addo | Afia Frimpomaa Asare Marfo | Josephine Mensah | Janice Osei Donkor | Amos Amoako-Adusei | Angela Opoku-Bona |

abstract

The Coronavirus disease 2019 is a public health problem which has had a significant impact on healthcare workers globally. Pharmacists have played a vital role in public education, approval of treatment options and management of infected individuals during the pandemic. This study assessed the knowledge and challenges of pharmacists in Ghana during the coronavirus disease 2019 pandemic. A cross-sectional study was conducted amongst registered pharmacists in Ghana from 13th July to 19th August, 2020 after seeking ethical approval. Data was collected using a pre-tested validated online questionnaire. Data was entered into Microsoft Excel and was exported to STATA 15.0 for statistical analysis. Factors influencing pharmacists’ ability to work and challenges were summarized as frequencies, percentages and a chart. A total of 488 pharmacists participated in this study. Official international health organization sites and media (N=442, 90.57%) and official government sites and media (N=404, 82.79%) were the most common sources of information on the coronavirus disease 2019 for pharmacists. Over a quarter of the participants (N=122, 28.48%) had been tested for the disease, and 354 (72.54%) had sufficient knowledge about the disease. A total of 398 (81.56%) participants admitted they had used their own personal protective equipment at work. Factors that positively influenced participants’ ability to work included motivation (N=36, 21.2%), a sense of duty (N=33, 19.4%) and enforcement of safety protocols (N=20, 11.8%). Non-adherence to safety protocols (N=41, 23.98%), fear of exposure to the virus (N=35, 20.47%) and inadequate provision of personal protective equipment (N=30, 17.54%) were common challenges faced. Pharmacists in various fields of practice demonstrated sufficient knowledge on the coronavirus disease 2019. Their expertise can be utilized to prevent and control the spread of the coronavirus disease 2019 in Ghana.

introduction

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) is a new severe pneumonia outbreak which emerged from Wuhan, China (World Health Organization, 2020a). It has attracted much attention worldwide, with a new coronavirus identified as the causative pathogen. The virus, initially named 2019-nCOV (2019 Novel Coronavirus) was subsequently called the SARS-COV-2 (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome Coronavirus 2) (Zhu et al., 2020). The World Health Organization (WHO) declared COVID-19 a pandemic on 11th March , 2020 (Khan et al., 2020; World Health Organization, 2020d). Consequently, several measures have been put in place to strengthen health care systems in most countries as part of strategies to manage the COVID-19 pandemic. Pharmacists, being essential players of the health care system, have played essential roles to complete the management cycle of the coronavirus outbreak. Pharmacists in various fields of practice have been instrumental in disease management, outbreak surveillance and research (Basheti et al., 2020). Pharmacists have also contributed to public health during the outbreak as infection prevention and control advocates, providing patient counselling, patient care, and patient support (Dawoud, 2020; Ung, 2020). Pharmacists as frontline health workers during the COVID-19 pandemic have worked tirelessly even during the lockdowns in community and hospital pharmacies, in research institutions and industries to offer invaluable services to the general public and communities in need (Bukhari et al., 2020; Ung, 2020). The International Pharmaceutical Federation (FIP) has emphasized on the effective role of pharmacists in preventing the spread of COVID-19 (International Pharmaceutical Federation, 2020b). Pharmacists often act as a reliable source of information for individuals who require advice about their medical conditions. In addition, community pharmacists triage patients, thus reducing the patient burden on healthcare facilities, including clinics and hospitals, amidst the pandemic globally. Pharmacists have also played a role in providing home deliveries and seamless care to patients with other ailments (Bukhari et al., 2020; International Pharmaceutical Federation, 2020a; Ung, 2020). Studies have shown that health workers’ ability to adhere to measures instituted to help prevent the spread of infections is influenced by their knowledge about the infection and the challenges faced in their line of work (Hamza, 2020). Studies about knowledge and challenges, therefore, serve to identify gaps that exist with regard to the knowledge, experience, preparedness and awareness level of pharmacists during the COVID-19 pandemic. These studies also enable policymakers to evaluate existing programmes and identify effective strategies to provide an enabling environment that encourages pharmacists to continue to offer their invaluable services (Muhammad et al., 2020). 

methodology

results

Sociodemographic characteristics of participants

A total of 488 pharmacists participated in this study with a response rate of 100%. Majority of the participants (288, 57.38%) were males, and almost half of the participants (238, 48.77%) were aged between 21 and 30 years. The median age group was 31-40 years. Three hundred and sixty-six participants (75%) work in the southern belt of Ghana and over half of the participants (253, 51.84%) had less than 6 years of working experience (Table 1). 

 

Table 1: Demographic characteristics of participants

Variable

Number

Percentage (%)

Sex

 

 

Male

280

57.38

Female

208

42.62

Age (years)

 

 

21-30

240

49.18

31-40

150

30.74

41-50

56

11.48

51-60

37

7.58

> 60

5

1.02

Regional Belts

 

 

Northern 

22

4.51

Middle/Central

100

20.49

Southern

366

75.00

Working Experience (years)

 

 

0-5

253

51.84

6-10

94

19.26

11-15

70

14.34

16-20

26

5.33

> 20

45

9.22

Direct involvement in COVID-19 Management

   

Directly involved

77

15.78

Not directly involved

411

84.22







Area of Practice of Participants

Two hundred and seventy-six participants (56.56%) were in community practice and 213 (43.65%) were in hospital practice. Public health, patient advocacy and consultancy constituted a total of three (0.6%) of the participants (Figure 1).

Figure 1: Areas of practice of participants




Training and testing on COVID-19

Four hundred and sixty-three (94.88%) of the participants indicated that the “no mask no entry” rule is enforced at their facilities. Two hundred and sixty-nine participants (55.12%) indicated that they have had an encounter with a suspected/confirmed case before. A total of 139 participants (28.48%) had been tested for COVID-19 with 5 (3.6%) taking the test more than three times (Table 2).

Table 2: Training and testing on COVID-19

Variable

Number

Percentage (%)

Training

   

Have received training

241

49.39

Haven't received training

247

50.61

Test

   

Have been tested

139

28.48

Haven't been tested

349

71.52

Number of times tested

   

Once

97

29.22

Twice

33

9.94

Thrice

4

1.2

More than thrice

5

1.51

Test result

   

Received

15

4.56

Not received

149

45.29



Source of information on COVID-19 

Official international health organization sites and media (442, 90.57%), official government sites and media (404, 82.78%), news media (346, 70.90%) and social media (309, 63.32%) were the most common sources of information on COVID-19 for pharmacists (Figure 2).

Figure 2: Sources of information on COVID-19 for pharmacists in Ghana



Knowledge of pharmacists about the COVID-19 pandemic

All the participants (100%) were aware that children and young adults are required to take measures to prevent contracting the virus. Three hundred and fifty-four participants (72.54%) had sufficient knowledge about COVID-19 (Table 3).

Table 3: Knowledge of pharmacists in Ghana about COVID-19 

Variable

Frequency (n, %)

Questions

 

The quarantine period is 2 weeks when one comes into contact with a suspected COVID -19 patient (False)

85 (17.42)

The quarantine period is 2 weeks when one comes into contact with a confirmed COVID -19 patient unknowingly (True)

446 (91.39)

Eating or contacting wild animals would result in the infection by the COVID-19 virus. (False)

388 (79.51)

A person with COVID-19 cannot infect others when a fever is not present. (False)

462 (94.67)

The COVID-19 virus spreads via respiratory droplets of infected individuals. (True)

481 (98.57)

Children and young adults do not need to take measures to prevent the infection by the COVID-19 virus. (False)

488 (100.00)

Recovery period for a mild case of coronavirus disease is 14-16 days (True)

356 (72.95)

Recovery period for a severe case of coronavirus disease is 3-6 weeks (True)

271 (55.53)

   

Level of Knowledge on COVID-19

 

Sufficient

354 (72.54)

Insufficient

134 (27.46)

 

Signs, symptoms and medications for the management of COVID-19

All the participants (100%) were aware that fever was a symptom of COVID-19. Three hundred participants (61.48%) were able to identify 6-10 signs and symptoms of COVID-19. A total of 466 participants (95.49%) were aware that zinc was useful in the management of COVID-19, and 302 participants (61.89%) were able to identify more than four medications useful in the management of COVID-19 (Table 4).

Table 4: Signs, symptoms and medications for the management of COVID-19

Variable

Frequency (n, %)

Signs and Symptoms

 

Fever

488 (100.00)

Headache 

448 (91.80)

Cough

483 (98.98)

Running nose

354 (72.54)

Nasal congestion

333 (68.24)

Fatigue

452 (92.62)

Muscle pain

308 (63.11)

Joint pain

226 (46.31)

Difficulty in Breathing

384 (78.69)

Loss of Appetite

178 (36.48)

Diarrhoea

316 (64.75)

Smell Disturbances

222 (45.49)

Skin rashes

59 (12.11)

Epigastric pain

114 (23.36)

Knowledge about Signs and Symptoms of COVID-19

 

0-5

45 (9.22)

6-10

300 (61.48)

> 10

143 (29.3)

Medications

 

Hydroxychloroquine

438 (89.75)

Doxycycline

158 (32.38)

Chloroquine

207 (42.42)

Enoxaparin

169 (34.70)

Azithromycin

465 (95.29)

Zinc

466 (95.49)

Vitamin C

455 (93.24)

Methylprednisolone

216 (44.26)

Knowledge about Medications for Management of COVID-19

 

0-4

186 (38.11)

> 4

302 (61.89)





Factors that influence pharmacists’ ability to work during the COVID-19 pandemic

Three hundred and ninety-eight participants (81.56%) indicated that they had used their own PPEs at work during the pandemic. Most pharmacists (439, 89.96%) had used their own face masks, while 3.69% had used their own boot covers. Other PPEs used included gloves (155, 31.76%), face shields (160, 32.79%), disposable scrubs (35, 7.17%) and hair covers (31, 6.35%). 

One hundred and seventy participants (34.8%) indicated, at least, one factor that positively influenced their ability to work during the COVID-19 pandemic. Frequently indicated factors included motivation from employers (36, 21.2%) and a sense of duty (33, 19.4%) (Figure 3).

Figure 3: Factors that positively influence pharmacists’ ability to work during the COVID -19 pandemic

Challenges pharmacists face during the COVID-19 pandemic

Four hundred and thirty-eight participants (89.75%) agreed that fear of contracting the virus from the workplace was a challenge and 465 participants (95.28%) agreed that fear of contracting the virus and transmitting it to family members was also a challenge. Stigmatization by friends and neighbours was identified as a challenge faced while working during the pandemic by 277 participants (56.77%). Two hundred and eight participants (42.62%) agreed that stigmatization from family was a challenge while 402 participants (82.38%) agreed that fear of encountering or taking care of a patient with COVID-19 unknowingly was a challenge. 

One hundred and seventy-one participants (35.04%) indicated, at least, one challenge they faced during the COVID-19 pandemic. Of this number, the commonest challenge faced were non-adherence to COVID-19 safety protocols by the public (41, 23.98%), fear of exposure to the virus (35, 20.47%) and inadequate provision of PPE (30, 17.54%) (Figure 4).

Figure 4: Challenges pharmacists face during the COVID -19 pandemic

 

Association between level of knowledge of participants and demographic characteristics

Training (p<0.001), being tested for COVID-19 (p=0.022) and encounter with a confirmed/suspected case (p<0.001) were significantly associated with the level of knowledge of pharmacists. However, sex, age, regional belt of practice, work experience and direct involvement in the management of COVID-19 cases were not significantly associated with the level of knowledge of participants about COVID-19 (Tables 5).

 

Table 5: Association of level of knowledge and demographics

Variable

Knowledge (n, %)

ꭓ2

 

P-value

 

Sufficient

Insufficient

Sex

 

 

 

 

Male

200 (71.43)

80 (28.57)

0.4081

0.5230

Female

154 (74.04)

54 (25.96)

 

 

Age (years)

 

 

 

 

21-30

167 (69.58)

73 (30.42)

5.5038

0.2390

31-40

115 (76.67)

35 (23.33)

 

 

41-50

43 (76.79)

13 (23.21)

 

 

51-60

27 (72.97)

10 (27.03)

 

 

> 60

2 (40.00)

3 (60.00)

 

 

Region

 

 

 

 

Northern

18 (81.82)

4 (18.18)

2.0715

0.355

Middle/Central

68 (68.00)

32 (32.00)

 

 

Southern

268 (73.22)

98 (26.78)

 

 

Working Experience (years)

       

0-5

173 (68.38)

80 (31.62)

6.7548

0.149

6-10

76 (80.85)

18 (19.15)

 

 

11-15

54 (77.14)

16 (22.86)

 

 

16-20

20 (76.92)

6 (23.08)

 

 

> 20

45 (68.89)

14 (31.11)

 

 

Direct involvement in COVID-19 Management

 

 

 

 

Directly involved

62 (80.52)

15 (19.48)

2.9217

0.087

Not directly involved

243 (71.05)

119 (28.95)

 

 

Training

 

 

 

 

Have received training

195 (80.91)

46 (19.09)

16.754

< 0.001

Haven't received training

159 (64.37)

88 (35.63)

 

 

Test

 

 

 

 

Have been tested

111 (79.86)

28 (20.14)

5.2214

0.022

Haven't been tested

243 (69.63)

106 (30.37)

 

 

Encounter with a confirmed/suspected case

 

 

 

 

Have encountered

215 (79.93)

54 (20.07)

16.4105

< 0.001

Haven't encountered

139 (63.47)

80 (36.53)

 

 

 

discussion

conclusion

Pharmacists in various fields of practice in Ghana demonstrated sufficient knowledge on COVID-19. Their expertise can be utilized to prevent and control the spread of the disease in Ghana. Most Pharmacists indicated that motivation from employers, a sense of duty and the provision and enforcement of safety protocols positively influenced their ability to work, while fear of contracting the virus and transferring to their families, stigmatization and taking care of COVID-19 patients unknowingly were challenges faced.

recommendation

Declaration of conflicting interest

The Authors declare that there is no conflict of interest.

 

Authors’ contribution

MNAOA, AFAM, JM, JOD, AAA and AOB conceptualized the study. MNAOA supervised the whole study, and all authors participated in its design and coordination. All authors coordinated data collection. MNAOA, AAA and JM analysed and interpreted the data. AFAM, JM, JOD, AAA and AOB drafted the manuscript. The manuscript was reviewed for intellectual content by all authors. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Funding

This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.

 

references

acknowledgements

Article Metrics

Views
0
Downloads
0