GHANAIAN COMMUNITY PHARMACISTS’ KNOWLEDGE LEVELS ON ADOLESCENT- FRIENDLY SEXUAL AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTHCARE SERVICES: A CROSS SECTIONAL STUDY ACROSS 4 REGIONS
Bridget Boatemaa Boahen | Lydia Asante | Mark Anum Nortey | Emmanuel Kwaku Ireland |
abstract
Community pharmacies have been globally recognized for their vital role in providing primary and reproductive healthcare services, particularly in delivering adolescent-friendly sexual and reproductive health services (AFSRHS). Positioned strategically within communities, these cadre of professionals have the potential to offer a range of essential services for adolescents. Despite this potential, limited research has been conducted to assess the knowledge levels of community pharmacists regarding AFSRHS and the readiness of community pharmacies to provide these services. This study aimed to address this gap by comprehensively assessing the knowledge levels of community pharmacists concerning AFSRHS and evaluating the readiness of community pharmacies to deliver these critical services. The findings provide valuable insights into opportunities for enhancing adolescent-friendly healthcare delivery within community pharmacy settings. In this quantitative cross-sectional study, we examined the knowledge levels of 192 community pharmacists across four diverse regions concerning AFSRHS. Utilizing a self-administered electronic questionnaire, we assessed three primary knowledge domains: understanding of basic concepts in adolescent sexual and reproductive health, awareness of barriers impeding the provision of these services, and familiarity with local policies and global guidelines governing adolescent health service policies. Additionally, we explored pharmacists' knowledge regarding the roles of healthcare providers in delivering AFSRHS. Knowledge categorization in the analysis was accomplished using a modified Bloom's classification, where a threshold of ≥ 80% was applied signifying adequate knowledge. This criterion served as the benchmark to determine the adequacy of knowledge pertaining to AFSRHS. The collected data were analyzed using Stata version 16. The demographic composition of the study participants included a majority of male respondents (62.5%) and 37.5% females among the 192 participants. In terms of professional experience, 39.6% reported 1 to 5 years as community pharmacists. Majority of respondents (74.5%) practiced in the Ashanti region. In terms of overall knowledge levels, a significant proportion (71.9%) demonstrated inadequate knowledge on AFSRHS, with a Mean Knowledge Score of 76.2 ± 10.13 SD. The study's findings underscore notable knowledge gaps among community pharmacists in the examined regions concerning AFSRHS. These findings highlight the need for further investigations to gather additional insights. Such studies can contribute to a more comprehensive understanding, enabling community pharmacists to enhance their role in providing effective and informed AFSRHS.
Keywords: Sexual and reproductive healthcare, Community pharmacist; Adolescent.
introduction
methodology
results
discussion
The findings of this study indicate that only a minority of community pharmacists i.e. 54 out of the 192 representing 28.1%, possessed overall adequate knowledge of AFSRHS. Many pharmacists demonstrated a lack of understanding of the definition of an adolescent, and a considerable number provided uncertain or incorrect responses regarding the varying needs of adolescents and the difficulties faced by health workers in addressing such needs. These gaps underscore significant deficiencies in pharmacists' knowledge concerning adolescent needs.
While the average knowledge score across all three subscales was 76.2 ± 10.13 SD; it fell short of the Bloom's classification requirement of healthcare professionals possessing at least 80% adequate knowledge scores (Ashebir et al., 2022; Feleke et al., 2021; K. Kaliyaperumal, 2008; Olum et al., 2020; Zhang et al., 2020). Furthermore, the WHO Global Standards for Quality Health-Care Services for Adolescents stress the importance of healthcare providers and support staff possessing the technical competence necessary for delivering effective health services to adolescents. This is fundamental to ensure that adolescents receive care that upholds their rights to information, privacy, confidentiality, non-discrimination and a non-judgmental attitude, while also showing them respect (UNAIDS, 2015).
These observations among community pharmacists within the four regions align with previous research (although limited) assessing the knowledge levels and training requirements of community pharmacists in areas such as family planning, emergency contraception pills (ECPs), the diagnosis and management of sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and HIV/AIDS, fertility services and other aspects of SRHS (Chin, 2011; Kappou & Drouvioti, 2022; Meredith et al., 2020).
For instance, a prior study examined the knowledge, attitudes and healthcare delivery practices of pharmacists towards adolescents, revealing that although the majority of the 948 surveyed pharmacists provided services to adolescents, a minority did not feel adequately trained or knowledgeable on specific adolescent issues. This lack of training and knowledge impacted the quality of pharmaceutical and SRHS provision to this population (Conard et al., 2003). A similar finding was reported by Corroon et al., 2016, which highlighted knowledge gaps and training deficiencies among community pharmacists in Kenya and Nigeria regarding aspects of SRHS, such as family planning. In their study, Meredith et al., 2020, emphasized the importance of providing community pharmacists with further training on SRH and youth-friendly services. Similarly, another study identified that pharmacists had knowledge gaps and were uncomfortable with prescribing contraceptives, underscoring the need for training and increased comfort levels among community pharmacists in providing SRH services (Lio et al., 2018).
Lastly, Ediyono's 2021 study, investigating the delivery of adolescent-friendly services by service providers other than pharmacists, yielded findings comparable to the present study. These findings underscore the necessity for improved knowledge and competencies in adolescent and youth services, emphasizing the potential impact of inadequate knowledge among providers in exacerbating barriers faced by adolescents in accessing AFSRHS (Gale & Watson, 2011).
conclusion
The study reveals significant knowledge gaps among community pharmacists within the studied regions regarding AFSRHS. While recognizing the importance of community pharmacists in the healthcare system, the findings underscore the urgent need for enhanced training and increased knowledge to address the identified gaps. Ensuring that community pharmacists possess the necessary competence and compassion is necessary for delivering effective AFSRHS. The study further reinforces the notion that inadequate knowledge among healthcare providers, including community pharmacists, can contribute to barriers faced by adolescents in accessing AFSRHS. This emphasizes the ongoing need for continuous professional development and training programs to strengthen their role in providing comprehensive reproductive healthcare services for adolescents.
Limitations
Despite the valuable insights gained from this study, limitations impact generalizability and interpretation. The geographical focus on four regions in Ghana may limit representation, as different regions may have unique factors influencing community pharmacists' knowledge. The study relied mainly on quantitative methods, lacking qualitative approaches like interviews, which could have provided a deeper understanding of factors influencing pharmacists' knowledge and contextual nuances in providing AFSRHS. These limitations emphasize the need for caution in generalizing findings and underscore the importance of future research that incorporate more regions and qualitative methodologies.